Decoding the Hiring Dilemma: Education vs. Experience


Decoding the Hiring Dilemma: Education vs. Experience

Posted on 27 April 2023

​When it comes to hiring a new employee, one of the biggest questions that arises is whether to prioritize experience or education. While there is no clear-cut answer, the decision ultimately depends on the industry and the nature of the work. Let's take a closer look at why education and experience matter in different industries and roles.

In industries that require technical or specialized skills, such as engineering or medicine, education is often crucial. These fields typically have specific requirements and regulations, and a certain level of education is necessary to obtain the necessary qualifications. In many cases, having a relevant degree or certification is a requirement for even being considered for the job.

For instance, let's consider the field of medicine. A career in medicine requires a significant amount of formal education, with a minimum of an undergraduate degree and often years of specialized training beyond that. This education is necessary to develop the knowledge and skills required to diagnose and treat patients effectively. In such industries, education holds greater weight than experience.

However, in other industries, experience may hold more value. In fields such as creative design, writing, or social media, the emphasis is often more on the candidate's portfolio, their past work experience, and their overall skillset than their formal education. Real-world experience can be invaluable in these industries, as it can provide insight and knowledge that cannot be taught in a classroom.

For example, in the field of writing. While a degree in English or creative writing can certainly be helpful, it is not always necessary for success in this field. Instead, employers may prioritize candidates who have a strong portfolio of published work, and who have demonstrated their ability to write effectively in various formats and styles. Similarly, in fields like sales or public relations, industry knowledge and interpersonal skills are critical, and experience may hold more weight than a formal education.

There are also roles that require a balance of both education and experience. For instance, in the field of marketing, a candidate with a strong educational background and relevant work experience may have an advantage. While a degree in marketing or business may be helpful, employers may also look for candidates who have experience with marketing campaigns or social media management, as well as a deep understanding of consumer behavior and market trends.

So, which is more important - experience or education? Ultimately, it depends on the industry and the specific role. While education can be crucial in fields that require specialized knowledge or technical skills, experience is often more valuable in creative or interpersonal roles. However, even in industries where education holds more weight, employers often prioritize candidates who have both education and experience.

At the end of the day, the most important thing is to look for candidates who have the skills, knowledge, and experience necessary to excel in the specific role. Employers should carefully consider the needs of their company and the position they are hiring for, and evaluate candidates based on a combination of factors, including their education, experience, skillset, and overall fit for the company culture.

Here at Platform Recruitment we've been developing our expertise for over 12 years, making us a leading recruitment agency based in North London.
We currently have clients with live roles, looking for exciting new talent to join their team – contact us now to find out more and see which opportunities we have for you in Software Development, DevOps, Mechanical, Hardware & Electronics, Life Sciences, Data Science, Manufacturing, QA and Engineering – as well as management, operations and support function roles.
Share this article

Job Alerts

Register with us to keep up to date with all of our latest, relevant jobs.